You are here: Home > About Us > Testimonials
Thanks so much for the wonderful Classic Baseball Shortbread Cookie treats.  Our family truly enjoyed every bite right down to the last morsel.  What a thoughtful and warm gesture.  Again we say "Thank you" for thinking of the Dawsons during the wonderful Hall of Fame Induction weekend. 
Vanessa, Andre, Darius and Amber Dawson

The cookies arrived at my homeon time and in perfect condition and the order for my brother and his son arrived in North Carolina in perfect condition and on time! This is my third order and I am always pleased with the ease of ordering, the packaging, the prompt delivery, the "Tin O Bunts" cans, butmost of all the delicious cookies! They always make our event, whether it is a tailgate party to a Major League baseball game to see the Washington Nationals or the Baltimore Orioles or a Little League celebration, a huge hit! They are always a home run and I'll be back for more next season.

Thank you.
L.K. Fairfax, VA

Cookies arrived in great shape. The gifts were well received by my customers! They enjoyed how good the cookies were, as well asthe story behind the product and how the proceeds help benefit a great cause. They also thought it was great that they came from Cooperstown, NY - the birthplace of baseball. Iplayed in a tournament inCooperstown back in September and I tried your cookies at a local restaurant. They tasted great and the baseball theme fit with my personality. The gifts stuck out from other vendor's gifts that my clients had received. Ordering the product went very smooth. Thank you for helping me provide great holiday gifts for my client base!

— J.G. Elk Grove Village, IL

Your cookies were a present for my husband who is a great baseball fan as well as a lover of shortbread. Thanks for providing a unique present "for the man who has everything"!

— M.K. Thiensville, WI

I sent my grandson (who is a baseball nut) the cookies as a congratulation gift for his excellent work in a State Scrabble Tournament. They were received in good condition and devoured shortly after. You make a very good product.

— M.F. Rockville Centre, NY

Hi Winnie,
I had sent the cookies to my son for his birthday. They arrived on his birthday even though I had only ordered them 3 business days ahead. He says they were in very good condition and tasted great! I also wanted to thank you so much for correcting the typo I made when entering his address on the website. You really went the extra mile for customer service. It really means alot to a mom who's son is 1600 miles away from her on his birthday! Many thanks!

— Diane Ft. Worth, TX

Yes, they arrived on time and in great condition. :) They're coaches gifts for my daughter's softball team, so we've not given them out yet, but we got some last year for Father's day and they were fantastic. We do like the charm of the smaller company.

— K.S. California

The order was received very shortly after the order was placed. The cookies were in good condition, packed very nicely in the cool tin. The "baseball" cookies were very, very good. My kids couldn't stay out of my baseball tin. Thank you, I will be ordering again in the future. The packaging and product will make for great gifts.

— J.M. Syracuse, NY guys were all very nice and helpful. Thank you for everything.

— Kami, Illinois

My daughter tells me that her boyfriend devoured the chocolate chip shortbreads even though he's not a real big cookie fan! The tin is now gracing their coffee table. Go Yankees!!

—W.H. Syracuse, NY

Hi Winnie:
I learned about your cookies from a magazine article. Was it Town and Country? Anyway, I held on to it for until it was time for my friend's b-day. He's a huge baseball fan. He thought it was terrific. Thanks so much.

—A.G. Los Angeles, CA.

I was told they were good, so I am pleased. Further, I thought your price points are reasonable and the packaging unusual

— M.V. Florida

yes, the cookies arrived on time and in good condition...we gave them as a gift. When we were in Coop at Thanksgiving time we bought some and they were delicious.

— S.W. Chatham, N.Y.

The cookies arrived in perfect condition, right on Valentine's day and my boys LOVED them. Keep up the good work!!! We will be ordering in the future

— Lisa

The product was wonderful. The person that received the cookies said they were awesome.

— T.V. Oak Ridge , TN.

Yes, the cookies arrived in good condition. I sent them to my parents in Arizona as a spring training kick-off and they were thrilled.

— Tracy Ann

The cookies were reported to be very good. They did arrive on time and the recipient was very pleased with both the cookies and the "cool tin". An interesting story; Someone in the neighborhood called the police. The responding officer went to the wrong house and handed the package of cookies to my son when he opened the door. My son said that both the cookies and the police were good folks!

— J.H. North Carolina

Winnie Drumm,
Thank you for your e-mail. Yes the cookies arrived in a timely manner and the recipients loved them. I definitely will be ordering from your company again. Thanks again your cookies really brightened my friend's day.

— Tania , Altamont Springs, FL

We received the cookies 2 days after they were ordered, and they were wonderful. Thank you.

Flossmore, IL

Yes the cookies arrived on time, in fact several days before the official opening day!! I guess I ordered too early? I received an email from the recipients and everything was OK. They reported that the cookies were very good. I appreciate your followup. It's an indication to me that you are interested in quality control.

— Dawn

Cookies were great and much appreciated!

— S.S. Medford, MA.

Yes, the cookies arrived and in good shape. I'm sure my son will like them--I purchased them for his birthday--May 14. He attends college at Marshall University in Huntington, West Virginia. Thanks so much and yes I'll be ordering again! God Bless!

— Judy

Cookies arrived on time. My son loves them! Great product! Thanks.

— L.W. Chicago, Illinois

Yes the order arrived on time and in perfect condition. I was ordering them for a big event in early May (if my husband does not find them and eat them) but thought I might use one or two this past weekend as kind of a teaser. However, the opportunity did not present itself. They will be a key item in a gift baskets and I will likely order more in the future. Thanks for the follow up and the courteous service.

— Kathy

Good Morning, Winnie! The baseball cookies arrived at my son's residence in good condition. He loved the surprise. He says that they taste yummy! Thanks for your prompt delivery. Enjoy a great baseball season.

B.K. San Diego, CA.

The cookies arrived in great shape and were enjoyed by all. Thank you

John, Charlotte, N.C.

And thanks for your follow-up e-mail. Yes, the cookies did arrive in good time and I'm sure that they were in good condition. The recipient was our grandson, finishing his second year at USC....and he is not fast with replying, though I'm sure we'll get a short note or a phone call before too long. He would have a lot of help in devouring the box undoubtedly! His Mom told me that she had been speaking to him and he said that they were a nice surprise. Thanks again for making such delicious cookies!


Hi, we really enjoyed the cookies. Thanks.


Our order was here in good time and I think our grandson was very pleased when he received his tin of baseball cookies! Thank you,

S.E. Edgarton, WI.

My mother-in-law, age 96, a Cardinals and cookie fan, could not have been more pleased with her gift of your shortbread baseball cookies. She looks forward to more. We will see to that. Thank you for your personal attention to this order.

R.M. Amityville, N.Y.

Just wanted to let you know that the cookies were a big hit with the party crowd on 5 November. And they were a wonderful way of combining the guest of honor's love of baseball with "a good deed" - central to the whole concept of becoming a Bar Mitzvah. Many thanks for your kind assistance, efficient follow through, and a truly wonderful product!

D.M. Virginia

The cookies arrived in good condition. They are a gift for my boss--the man who has everything. However, he is a neonatologist, is originally from Long Island and has an interest in baseball. The story of Pathfinder Village hit a note with me and I think it will with him too. It is more than just a gift.

P.R. Louisville, KY.

Yes, the cookies arrived in good condition and in reasonable time. I sent them to someone other than myself. Being a baseball fan, he loved them and went through them all in two days. I would definitely order from you again. Customer service was excellent. The person who took my order actually pulled off the road when she was driving and wrote down my order because I had a problem with your website. Now that's good customer service.

J.W. (happy customer) Balston Spa, N.Y.

I believe they did arrive on time--and the recipients thrilled with them--as my uncle, the ultimate recipient, played for the Mets in the '73 World Series. :) LOVED the cookies!

XOXO, R.S. Salt Lake City, Utah

Cookies were great and arrived on time, thank you for the great service.

J.G. Richmond, VA

The cookies arrived in perfect condition. I bought them for my Dad. He was thrilled. He said they are great. He is a retired baker so he should know. I thought since he is such a Yankee fan he would get a kick out of them. Now lets hope the Yankees win.

S.G. Milford, CT.

I'd love to be on your e-mail list!

A.C. San Francisco, CA.

Thank you so much for answering my email about cookie delivery. My kids (the baseball nuts) received their packages and are thrilled. How nice of you to take the time to address my concerns. I learned about your company through an ad in "Town and Country" magazine and intend to be a returning customer. Go White Socks!

C.T. Ohio

The cookies did arrive, in excellent condition, and are just perfect for the event - combining the bar mitzvah's love of baseball (Yankees) with the family's desire to support a worthy cause - something I try to have all b'nai mitzvah clients strive for. Many thanks to the Cooperstown Cookie Company for providing a wonderful product and a valuable service to the community.

D.L. Fairfax Station, VA.

The cookies arrived on time and in very good condition. They are delicious! Thanks very much for the great service and the follow up email.

P.A. Beverly Hills, CA.

All was great, thanks.

D.P. N.Y., N.Y.

Thanks for the email. The cookies arrived on time and in good condition. I look forward to sending them again as a gift.

J.B. N.Y.

The cookies arrived at my son's apartment in a timely fashion and he loves them. I have ordered before and the cookies are delicious!!!

L.W. Chicago, IL.

My grandson received the cookies - on time - and was tickled pink. They were in good condition and he liked the tin. Although they couldn't completely eliminate the pain they did help to soften the Yankees loss. Thank you.

N.L. N.Y., N.Y

We received our cookie order in timely and excellent condition. Thank you for requesting feedback! We already look forward to placing our next order. Keep up the great work!!

F.M. Carmel, CA.

Everything was as expected, in very good condition. The quality of cookies is excellent and they arrived on time. Thanks and I will be placing an order again soon.

S.L. Livingston, TX.

Our folks loved them. Thanks.

T.S. Windsor, CA..

Yes, my friend was very pleased with her cookies. Thanks for a pleasant shopping experience once again.

K.S. Grosse Ille, MI.

Everything arrived in good condition and the cookie recipients were both pleased and impressed! Thank you for a quality product and good quality control re feedback.

J.M. Carmel, CA.

HAPPY ANNIVERSARY!!! We wish you every success!! We will happily continue to be among you customer base of support!

J.M. New York

The cookies arrived today....perfect timing for the World Series game tonight! They are wonderful...thanks so much!

N.K. Kingston, N.Y.

Thanks for following up. Great customer service!

A.C. San Francisco, CA.

The cookies did arrive on time and in perfect condition. I was very pleased with the packaging, it looks exactly as it did on the website. The cookies have not yet been tasted because they are a b-day gift for my father, who's a big Red Sox fan - and I won't be seeing him until this weekend. I look forward to giving him the tin of cookies, though, it's a unique gift and a perfect one for someone who loves both cookies and baseball!

E.B. Boston, MA.

I was quite pleased with the shipment and presentation of the cookies. I plan on giving them to my Father-in Law for Christmas. He is a huge baseball fan and thought this would make a nice gift for him.

E.M. Tempe, AZ.

The cookies arrived promptly and in good condition.

D.W. Hopkinton, MA.

I must commend The Cooperstown Cookie Company for their excellent customer relations. I certainly will use you again for gifts for my baseball fan friends.

J.G. Richmond, VA.

The cookies are great. They arrived on time - presentation was wonderful. I would recommend these cookies to any baseball fan. Its great to find local business who cater to the "Year round Fan". Much Thanks

B.D. Albany, N.Y.

Cookies arrived on time and in good condition and were delicious and fresh. Thank you very much.

K.S. Ft. Payne, AL.

The whole experience was very pleasant, easy to order etc. The cookies arrived sooner than I expected and in perfect condition. I was very pleased with them. I'm using them for Christmas gifts. I like to send friends small gift baskets at Christmas time and I like to have something from New York State to send to non-local friends. It also helps that my husband is a huge baseball fan. Heard about your company in the Albany Times Union. Plus I'm glad Pathfinder Village is involved and gets some support from your company. Keep up the good work!

S.C. Schenectady, N.Y.

The cookies were a birthday present for my father (89).He received them today and both he and my mom loved them. Thanks.

T.B. Tupper Lake, N.Y.

They arrived as promised and the container is really pretty! It's a gift so no nibbles yet! It promises to be a yummy gift! Thanks!

E.L. Ovedo, FL.

I did receive them and I am very happy with them. They have yet to be sampled because I am giving them to my two oldest children who played baseball in Cooperstown back in 1999 and 2001. It was the coolest experience. I was so happy to find your add in a magazine while I was at the doctors one day... Thank you. If you know of any other things that would be wonderful memorabilia - that would be awesome. Thanks again and I look forward to seeing the looks on my kids faces when they see what is in the tins that I have wrapped so funny.

K.O. Upper Saddle River, N.J.

I got the cookies, they are a Christmas present, so I didn't open up the tin to look at the cookies, but the box and tin are in perfect condition. I got the cookies for my mom, she is a shortbread cookie junkie, and she was crazy about them the last time I got them for her, so I am sure I'll get the same reaction this time.

C.C. Northbrook , IL.

The cookies have arrived and are great!

T.B. Rockville, MD.

This was a gift — the recipient loved them. I enjoy dealing with your company — quality product and quality people!

A.M. Pittsburgh, PA.

Winnie — the cookies arrived and the recipient was very pleased with them — thanks.

D.R. Texas

I am appreciative of your follow-up when there were delivery problems, and now this inquiry, re: my satisfaction. I only hope the cookies taste as good as everything else I have experienced with your company.

S.B. Nevada


L.L. Keene, New Hampshire

They certainly make a great gift for our business customers. Thank you.

D.S. Cooperstown, N.Y.

We were very pleased will the total service.

M.R. Atlanta, GA.

The cookies arrived very quickly and everyone loved them. Great product.

N.R. Albany, N.Y.

They were a gift for my grandfather and he loved them!

A.S. Shorewood, Wisconsin

The cookies arrived on time in excellent condition. All the recipients were very pleased as was I with own order. I will definitely order some more!

D.L. West Hartford, CT.

The recipient LOVED them. We also ordered some for ourselves and are savoring every one! The cookies arrived intact and in perfect condition, and very, very quickly. Thanks, and we will absolutely order again.

M.S. Beaver Creek, Ohio

The cookies are great and arrived in perfect baseball shape.

L.R. Chicago, IL.

Chris loved the shortbread, which he received a couple of days after I had placed the order. I was so happy to discover your company as I leafed through Town and Country, which I was waiting to pick up a rental car. I hope to have the opportunity to use Cooperstown Cookie Company again. With best wishes for a wonderful 2006.

C.L. Colorado

Cookies arrived on time and were/ are very tasty. Thanks for the prompt service.

E.C. Burlington, Vermont

The cookies were delivered on time and in great condition! We are using them as sponsor thank you gifts for a baseball themed fundraising event! The sponsors loved them!

LB, Alzheimer's Association, Memphis, TN

The cookies were in tip-top shape and well appreciated by our son, his wife, and our grandson in Honolulu. Thank you.

The cookies were a huge hit in Minnesota. It's a baseball loving family (Twins, Royals, Indians, and Nationals!), and a cookie-loving family, too. Your fame is spreading coast to coast.

SR, Cooperstown, NY

I received your cookies in terrific order and tested one! It was really good. I'm using them as a corporate gift to a contact I do some work with and I'm sure they will be a crowd pleaser!

Cindy R, Allentown, PA

The person who I ordered the cookies for said they were awesome. I'll be ordering more in the future.


Thanks so much for sending my Dad another tin of cookies!! He was very excited to receive the gift!! He called me immediately and let me know they arrived!! It is indeed a pleasure to do business with a company like yours. I am sure I will use you for gifts in the future!

TVH, Metaine, LA

The cookies were a big hit! They arrived in time, in excellent condition - thank you very much. My three children (twin boys age 6, and a daughter age 5) were all on the same baseball team this spring. We gave a box to the head coach and the assistant coach - they just loved them! We are looking forward to doing business with you again in the future. I understand you may be expanding into other sports - we look forward to that as well! Thank you again.


I ordered your baseball cookies, for my brother-in-law, and everything was just great. I look forward to placing more orders in the future. Again thank-you.

CB, Rio Rancho, N.M.

They were a gift for my dad - I am in Australia so I will unfortunately not be able to taste them, but he says they are very good!


I am glad to report the cookies were received by the person we sent them to, well wrapped with the right messege. Everyone enjoyed them. Thanks. Perfect.


The cookies were a thank you gift and I have spoken to the recipient and he was very pleased. Keep up the good work! Thanks.

Mike, Beacon, NY

The cookies are wonderful...I purchased them for my husband who is a huge Lorna Doone Fan not to mention a baseball fan! He really liked them. Packaging is great and they arrived quickly and without injury.


The cookies arrived today, June 10; it took just two days for the package to get here. Thank you very much.

RM, Bellevue, WA

They were outstanding and the ones I gave as a gift were a major league hit!

Mayor Ardell F. Brede, Rochester, MN

The cookies were great!! They shipped just fine everything seemed to be in one piece!

JG, Glenville, IL

Perfect!! And thanks for your reply. My niece had called me to thank me for the gift.

SB, Vero Beach, FL

We LOVED them! My husband and Father-in-law are HUGE Red Sox Fans and they enjoyed their early Father's Day treat. I sent them from our new baby, Aiden, who is our little Red Sox Fan (10 weeks old). So they both laughed when they received a package from Aiden. Aiden's first baseball game was in the womb at the World Series and half of his clothes are related to baseball. Thanks for making the day of my baseball nuts. Thank you!


Good Morning- The cookies arrived yesterday... I got them for my father for father's day.... I didn't expect them to get here so fast. Thanks! So I gave them to him last night as an early father's day present. He is a huge baseball fan and really likes shortbread cookies. Your cookies past with flying colors!!!! He thought they were great. My 4-year-old son, shared the first pack with his grandpa. I'm glad I read about you in the Sporting News. Thanks!

LCW, Manhattan, KS.

The cookies arrived on time and they were in excellent condition. The cookies are delicious. I was very pleased with them. Thank you!


Winnie - The cookies arrived today and they were perfect! They have to be the best cookies I've had since we were kids growing up in Central New York ( Baldwinsville ) and my mom made everything with real butter. This truly is a taste to treasure. I wish you all the best in your business. It is a wonderful product and an even more wonderful association you have with Pathfinder Village.

Deb, Granite City, IL

Hello, Just arrived back from my honeymoon. The cookies were excellent! They arrived on time and in great condition. I will definitely bookmark your website and likely order again in the future. Thanks again!

ZS, New Canaan, CT

Dear Friiend: We had you send the cookies to our dentist who is a big baseball fan. They arrived in a timely manner and he loved their taste. Thanks.

PH, Charleston, SC

They were great -- a big hit. Thank you!

TT Washington Crossing, PA

Hi, The cookies were sent as a gift, and I believe they arrived promptly. By chance I just returned from visiting the family and was able to sample them for myself. As the family reported, they were perfectly delicious.


The cookies are excellent. I have your email stored in my favorites, so I can order some more in the future.

Carrie, Stockton, CA

I ordered these for coaches' gift for our little league team. I saw your article in the Press Enterprise and thought that was a great idea. I will definitely be telling people about you. Thank You so much.

KS, Lake Elsenore, CA

The package was beautifully wrapped and the cookies are delicious. Neat idea!!! Thanks also for the extra effort in getting them out in quick fashion.

DB, Wall Township, NJ

I read about your cookies the Trenton Times newspaper and I thought they were neat and unique. I sent the cookies to my dad (who loves cookies and baseball) as an early Father's day gift. They did arrive in a timely fashion and he said they are delicious (this is a true compliment coming from a genuine cookie connoisseur).

GV, Fort Collins, CO.

Dear Sir, My name is JL and I'm in 4th grade. I am doing a project on what to do and what to see at Cooperstown. I found your website and need more information. Can you send me a pamphlet and/or sample of your products? Do you give tours? Do you a map of your store or factory. Please send any information As Soon As Possible; my project is due May 10th. JL, Boardman, Ohio Thank you so much for the cookies and all the information you sent to me. I got an A+ on my project and now I get to eat the cookies.

Sincerely, JL.

They arrived perfectly and are absolutely delicious! Thank you.

KL, Ewing, NJ

We ordered the cookies for 3 b-ball players who have lived with us during the summer months while playing in college summer leagues. The cookies are wonderful. We will send them their care packages soon (with some lemonade) and they will appreciate them very much. They arrived much faster than I thought they would. Thank you. I'm quite sure I will be a repeat customer and one of the players (if not two) who will receive the cookies will be drafted this summer.

Nick Hundley (U of AZ) and Danny Mocny (Long Beach State U).

Fun stuff.

JM, Alexandria, MN

Dear Winnie, I sent these cookies as a gift, but I just received a phone message yesterday telling me how much they were appreciated, so it appears my gift was well received! She also noted what delicious shortbread cookies they were -- frankly, she really raved about them! I found a mention of your cookies in a daily food industry update, and wanted to follow up, as we're all big baseball fans and had visited Cooperstown on vacation a few years ago. I wish you success with your business!

ET, Fair Oaks, CA

Oh, are you sweet! We just got back from Las Vegas, and YES, the cookies were there when we arrived and were they AMAZING. Really, they are simply fabulous shortbread cookies, and so cute. The packaging is wonderful, too. Thank you, thank you, thank you! You did a wonderful job, and we'll be sure to place more orders in the future. Best to you and everyone at Cooperstown Cookie Company and Pathfinder Village!

JC, San Francisco

Actually the friend I sent them to just called yesterday. She loved them.


Everything was great — service, cookies, delivery, and packaging — the cookies and you guys are terrific! Thanks!

KC, Chappaqua, NY

Dear Winnie, I sent your cookies to my 81-year-old uncle in Philadelphia who is an avid baseball fan for his birthday. He called the other night to thank my husband and I. It was a great gift for him. He loves baseball and cookies. I'm very glad that the Gourmet Food Mall keeps me updated on new vendors. He really got a great kick out of it and the cookies arrived in good condition. He hadn't eaten one yet but knowing him, they won't last long. Thanks for a unique gift idea.

Regards, Cheryl

I was actually kind of jealous that I had to send them to someone else for my boss. They look delicious and the packaging is great. I will definitely remember your company in future. Also I don't know if it will be helpful to you to know. But the reason we were aware of your company was because of a feature "article" email from the Cooperstown Chamber of Commerce.

L Holland

Hello - the cookies arrived in good shape, and were a big hit for opening day with my two favorite baseball fans. Thank you!


Hi --Got a nice Thank You call from the young ball-player nephew these were shipped to, so evidently they arrived in good shape and were tasty!


They were a gift--they got to California in record time and the recipient said they were very good!


The cookies arrived on time, in good shape and were delicious. My husband who plays baseball in Cooperstown every July loved them. Thanks.


My son tells me that the cookies were delicious and that he really appreciated receiving them as a gift. The cookies were a gift for my son-in-law's birthday and he was very pleased with them. They arrived on time and in great condition.


The cookies did indeed arrive on time. They were a gift for my brother, who says he enjoyed them immensely. I can't vouch for their condition, but since he somehow forgot to offer to share, I think it's safe to assume that he wasn't just being polite. I see this becoming an annual tradition (the sending him your cookies part. I'm hoping that next time he'll let me try one).

Thanks, Christopher

I sent the cookies to friends, who got a good laugh over it because a) I'm a sports journalist and b) a huge baseball fan (specifically of the Chicago Cubs). I sent the cookies signaling that this interminable winter will soon end with Opening Day! Both of my friends thoroughly enjoyed the cookies.


Delicious! I want to make an additional gift order.

MD, Ridge, NY

Everything was great. Everyone has loved the cookies! Do you sell or plan to sell cookies in any other designs or flavors?

Thank you, Perri

Dear Winnie: Both orders of cookies were received within 2-3 days in perfect shape. Our friends said the cookies were delicious and thought it was a great gift idea. They enjoyed the trivia question, too. I will definitely send more cookies to other friends in the future.

Cave Creek, AZ

Hello, The cookies arrived on time, in good condition, and are delicious! I also like the tin they come in. I wonder whether you will consider expanding your selection to include other kinds of cookies, perhaps with chocolate!

NG, Montclair, NJ

Sweetheart, cookies from Cooperstown. You are something. Thank you.

Love, Irv (email from ex-husband after receiving cookies from ex-wife)

Everyone loved the cookies. They were extremely tasty. Someone said, "Is there ever a bad shortbread?" and I thought, "yes, there is." But not yours.


The cookies arrived on time and in good condition... I bought them for our get together this week when all of us who share season tickets for the Oakland A's draw for games.


I sent them to my nephews and they arrived yesterday in good condition. They absolutely loved them and the three year old said it was the best cookie he ever had! Thank you...


Hi Winnie, I ordered the cookies for my boyfriend and from what he told me they arrived in spectacular and delicious condition. Thanks a lot!

The cookies arrived on time and in good shape — both were for gifts so unfortunately I didn't get to taste them, but they looked beautiful — a nice presentation!

Anne M

The cookies were a birthday gift to my mother, a baseball fan exultant at the return of baseball to DC.


The cookies arrived within 2 days & were delicious. And, the tin was great too. Because everyone enjoyed them so much, I placed a follow-up order.


The recipient of the cookies told us they were delicious and very clever idea. He is a huge baseball fan, thus our idea for the gift. They were shipped quickly and arrived in good condition.

JH, Long Island City, NY

They arrived in perfect condition and very quickly (ordered on a Saturday morning and they were received by the recipient on Monday or Tuesday). Very pleased. By the way, I learned about the company in that small piece in the NY Times Wednesday food section (March 2nd).

Chris S, NYC

They arrived on time and in great condition. They tasted great and were a hit! Someone even said - wow these are what real cookies are supposed to taste like! Packaging was a hit too!


Hi there, The cookies arrived about three days after my order - very timely. I am giving them to a friend of mine who is hosting me for a few days in New Orleans. I will let you know toward the end of this month what he thought of them. He is a baseball fanatic and I thought he would like the packaging.

Regards, Ray

They loved them and have visited your nephew is a baseball nut so thank you.

Cathy A

I was so pleased to see the package arrive within days (or should I say hours) of the order. They are the perfect gift for my nephew. I am pleased with the company's commitment to the community and the involvement with Down's people in your product.

My thanks, Brenda

The cookies came quickly (yesterday) and look to be in excellent condition. They are for a birthday later in the month, so they have not yet been sampled. I was also happy that you took the trouble to include a card.


The cookies arrived even earlier than expected, and in perfect condition. Thank you very much.

Jane C

Hi - the cookies arrived perfectly, and were a huge hit! I gave them as a Valentine's present, and my baseball fan loved them! Thanks!


Yes, I sent them as a Valentines Gift, and they arrived BEFORE I thought they would. This pleased me very much. They loved them very much, and they were all together. I would like to thank you for how well this worked out. I might order them again in the future.

Thank You, TO

Winnie- The cookies were in good condition and arrived on time. My boyfriend is a huge baseball fan and loved them! Thanks!


Just wanted to let you know that the cookies arrived on time and they were delicious. They were a Valentine's gift for my husband and he was delighted with them and he also enjoyed the trivia questions. I was especially impressed with your company's customer service -- the woman who helped me place my order couldn't have been nicer. I definitely plan to order from your company again. Keep up the good work!

Sincerely, BM

I received a call from my friends in North Carolina and they raved about the cookies, thought they were wonderful and yes, they arrived in good condition and in a very reasonable amount of time. Thank you for a job "well done" I am sure we will be placing more orders in the future.

Sincerely, Anne

Hi Winnie, Thanks for the follow-up. I got the order yesterday. I will take these cookies in to work Monday. We have a whole staff at the Bank where I work who are Baseball nuts. I saw the write up about you in the newspaper last week, and thought it would be a neat surprise at the office. I will let you know what people think.

Thanks, John

Ms. Drumm, The cookies arrived even earlier than expected, and in perfect condition. Thank you very much.


Yes they did arrive (quickly). 1 tin is a gift; the other, well, 'tis almost gone! They're great!


Both boxes arrived in an extremely timely fashion and in excellent condition.

EM, Albany, NY

I received the cookies. They were in great condition, and they were great. Your service was excellent. Thank you!


Dear Winnie, The cookies were a gift for my cousin in California. I am extremely pleased with your service and want to let you know that I was especially happy to see that you accepted PayPal payment. When I found the ad for your cookies in the paper I KNEW that this was going to be the perfect Christmas gift. Your company has allowed me to send a little bit of Cooperstown to California and in the form of a baseball sweetie. Wonderful idea!


The cookies arrived in perfect shape. Thank you so much. I love the plaid box. It is a bit more festive.

Thanks for the cookies...just tasted one and they are delicious and the artwork is wonderful. Will pass around to staff here.

Just got the cookies today and they are wonderful - cute and delicious. I will definitely be placing an order for my son's Bar Mitzvah - probably 150 packages. I will get back in touch as soon as I have a better idea of the number...congratulations on creating such a great product that helps out people in your community.


Dear Winnie, We're avid baseball fans and when I saw the article in our local newspaper, Newsday, AND my son's birthday coming up in just two weeks, I HAD to order them. I'm sure they'll be great.

AF, Great Neck, NY

The tin is adorable; unfortunately, I can't sample the cookies. They're a birthday gift for my son. His birthday is February 12th and it's the perfect gift...of course, he's going to be 27 and I'll be adding a little money with it, but he is an avid Yankees my entire family is... AND, he actually played on Doubleday Field when he was 13 years old. So, I'm sure he's going to appreciate the gift. (Maybe I'll dig up the pics of him that we took in Cooperstown and include them with the cookies!)

Regards, Andrea

Thank you the cookies were a big hit-- the child does not want to eat them-a great idea- everything was perfect.



Hi, The cookies were delicious! They arrived in excellent shape... From when they were ordered it took 2 days to get them. I thought the price was right and was pleased with the product. Thanks for putting a smile on my daughters face.

Sincerely, Cindy

The order arrived so quickly, it was incredible.

I wanted to celebrate the return of pitchers and catchers to Spring Training, and I have plenty of time to get these tins to the office. Thanks from all the Yankee and Mets fans I work with (and me - I'm one of the Yankee fans)

Laura D

I loved them ...They're for my boyfriend for Valentine's Day. I got them right on time so.... great job and thank you sooo much! I also told my friend about them and she ordered some on the same day for her boyfriend who's also a baseball fanatic.

Best to you, S.